Two prints, two different cuts
The Hipster Goldfish and Original Horses are both women’s fairtrade styles from Thunderpants, but they are not the same fit. The Hipster Goldfish sits lower at the waist, while the Original Horses is a full brief that sits just under the navel. That difference in rise is the first thing to weigh before you choose a print.
Both use the same 90% cotton and 10% spandex fabric, and both have a flat front with a soft gusset made from the same fabric as the outer garment. Neither uses grippy elastic; the waist and leg bands are made from the same soft fabric. So the decision comes down to rise, coverage, sizing and which print you want to wear.
Hipster Goldfish: lower rise, five sizes
- Hipster Goldfish: The Hipster Goldfish is a flat-fronted style with a soft gusset made from the same fabric as the outer garment. A flat front and soft gusset keep the front smooth and comfortable, which suits everyday wear.

Hipster Goldfish - Hipster Goldfish: This cut is designed to sit in the natural crease at the top of the leg, cover your bum and reach to your high hip area. That is a lower rise than the Original, so it will not come up to the navel.
- Hipster Goldfish: Thunderpants recommends the hipster if you are flat in the tummy and/or short in the rise to the waist. If that describes you, the lower rise is likely to sit comfortably rather than dig in or roll.
- Hipster Goldfish: The Hipster Goldfish is available in sizes XS, S, M, L and XL. That is five sizes, one fewer than the Original Horses, so larger wearers may need to check the size chart carefully.
Original Horses: full brief, seven sizes
- Original Horses: The Original Horses is a full brief that sits in the natural crease at the top of the leg and just under the navel. This higher rise gives more coverage across the tummy than the Hipster.

Original Horses - Original Horses: The Original Horses style was first made in 1995. It is the longer-established cut, so if you already know you like the Original fit, the Horses print is a straightforward choice.
- Original Horses: The Original Horses is available in sizes S, M, L, XL, 2XL and 3XL. This extends to 3XL, so it covers a wider size range than the Hipster Goldfish.
- Original Horses: Thunderpants describes the Original as the comfy undies that don’t go up your bum. If ride-up is your main frustration with other underwear, the full brief cut is designed to stay in place.
Fit and sizing side by side
The Hipster Goldfish and Original Horses share the same fabric and band construction, but their rise and size ranges differ. Use the size charts for each style rather than assuming your usual size carries over.
- Rise: Hipster Goldfish sits at the high hip; Original Horses sits just under the navel.
- Coverage: Original Horses is a full brief; Hipster Goldfish is a lower-cut hipster.
- Size range: Hipster Goldfish: XS–XL. Original Horses: S–3XL.
- Fabric: Both: 90% cotton, 10% spandex.
- Bands: Both: waist and leg bands made from the same soft fabric, no grippy elastic.
When the Hipster may roll down
Thunderpants is candid about one limitation of the hipster cut: for many people, the hipster does not reach over the apex of the tummy roll, and at that point gravity can take over and the hipster will roll down. If you have a fuller tummy or a longer rise, the Original Horses or a higher-waisted style may stay in place more reliably.
The Hipster Goldfish is recommended if you are flat in the tummy and/or short in the rise to the waist. That is not a rule, but it is a useful starting point. If you are between the two, the Original Horses offers more coverage and a higher rise without adding grippy elastic.
Print character: goldfish vs horses
Both prints are by Greta Menzies. The Hipster Goldfish features goldfish, which are a Chinese symbol of good fortune and prosperity. The Original Horses features a whinnying horse print. Neither print is described as hand-painted or hand-dyed in the supplied information, so do not assume a special dye method; the care instructions are the same for both.
If you want a print with a bit of symbolic luck, the goldfish is the obvious pick. If you prefer an animal print with a more classic, galloping feel, the horses print is the one.
Care for both prints
- Wash: Use a gentle detergent in a cold machine wash.
- Dry: Dry on the line, not in the drier.
- Avoid: Do not soak or bleach your Thunderpants items, to preserve the vibrant colours and life of the fabric.
A note on front room
Both the Hipster Goldfish and Original Horses are flat-fronted styles. If you require extra room in the front, Thunderpants suggests looking at their Pouch Fronted garments instead. The supplied information for these two prints does not include pouch-front options, so if that is a priority, check the Pouch Fronted range separately.
Which print suits you?
Choose the Hipster Goldfish if you prefer a lower rise that sits at the high hip, you are flat in the tummy or short in the rise, and you like the goldfish print. Choose the Original Horses if you want a full brief that sits just under the navel, you need a size above XL, or you prefer the horses print. Both are made in New Zealand from the same cotton-spandex fabric and share the same simple care routine.



